Your cart is empty.
Critical Condition - Replacing Critical Thinking with Creativity

Critical Condition

Replacing Critical Thinking with Creativity

by Patrick Finn
Subjects Education, Education
Hide Details
Paperback : 9781771121576, 145 pages, June 2015

Table of contents

Table of Contents for
Critical Condition: Replacing Critical Thinking with Creativity by Patrick Finn


Preface: An Invitation

Chapter 1 A Foolish Question: Isn't It Time We Replaced Critical Thinking?

Chapter 2 The Baby and the Bathwater: The Birth of Critical Thinking

Chapter 3 A Hitch or Two: Polemic, Violence, and the Case for Critical Thinking

Chapter 4 We Can't Go On Together (with Suspicious Minds)

Chapter 5 An Immodest Proposal: Let's Replace Critical Thinking with Creative, Loving, Open-Source Thought

Chapter 6 “Sure, It Works in Practice, but Will It Work in Theory?”

Chapter 7 Conclusion: An Open Invitation-Some Final Ideas and Questions





Should we stop teaching critical thinking? Meant as a prompt to further discussion, Critical Condition questions the assumption that every student should be turned into a “critical thinker.”
The book starts with the pre-Socratics and the impact that Socrates’ death had on his student Plato and traces the increasingly violent use of critical “attack” on a perceived opponent. From the Roman militarization of debate to the medieval Church’s use of defence as a means of forcing confession and submission, the early phases of critical thinking were bound up in a type of attack that Finn suggests does not best serve intellectual inquiry. Recent developments have seen critical thinking become an ideology rather than a critical practice, with levels of debate devolving to the point where most debate becomes ad hominem. Far from arguing that we abandon critical inquiry, the author suggests that we emphasize a more open, loving system of engagement that is not only less inherently violent but also more robust when dealing with vastly more complex networks of information.
This book challenges long-held beliefs about the benefits of critical thinking, which is shown to be far too linear to deal with the twenty-first century world. Critical Condition is a call to action unlike any other.


``Patrick Finn has written a book for the academy, but its implications are much wider. The critical thinking that drove the academics who wanted to ‘teach him a lesson’ by beating him in debate is well represented outside the Ivory Tower as well (think Question Period). But there is a growing awareness—and this book is part of it—that progress, collaboration, and creativity move hand in hand; that the emphasis belongs on ‘and,’ not ‘but.’ Finn is careful to differentiate critical thinking of the constructive kind from the rest; it is puzzling why it gets academics in such a huff. But surely that is a reason for reading it!''

- Jay Ingram, science writer and broadcaster, author of The End of Memory: ANatural History of Aging and Alzheimer's (2015)

``In this engaging and important book, Patrick Finn attacks traditional critical thinking for promoting hurt, anger, suspicion, and violence. He argues persuasively that critical thinking encourages the use of speech as a tool for dominance, control, and repression. He makes an eloquent and revolutionary plea for replacing critical thinking with ‘creative, loving, open-source thought.’ Critical Condition should be read by everyone who cares about the harmonious advance of the human project, particularly in the universities, but also in the world beyond.''

- Philip Slayton, president, PEN Canada, author of Mayors Gone Bad (2015)